Chapter IV
K 53–60
Gauḍapādacharya revisits the notion of cause and effect in order to free the seeker from habitual dependence upon causal thinking.
The intellect naturally seeks a cause for every object and every phenomenon. This approach is appropriate for empirical transactions but becomes an obstacle when the goal is liberation.
Accordingly, Advaita initially employs the language of cause and effect—for example, by saying that gold is the material cause of an ornament. As the teaching unfolds, it reveals that the cause and the effect are not truly different. This effectively dissolves the very notion of a cause-effect relationship.
A relationship can exist only between two distinct entities, not between two essentially the same things. Thus, just as there is ultimately no independent relationship between gold and the ornament, there is no real causal relationship between Consciousness and the world. This means that there is no real creation. Alternatively stated, the experienced world has no independent existence. The world is mithya. A doubt could arise.
Swami Paramarthananda says that the term ‘mithya’ conveys four essentially the same ideas:
1. Origination of the world is ultimately negated;
2. Independent existence of the world is negated;
3. Appearance and experience of the world are accepted; and
4. This appearance is due to ignorance (avidya) or Maya.
Maya consists of time, space, and causation. It has no independent reality and is comparable to magic. From the empirical standpoint, birth and destruction are meaningful concepts. From the standpoint of Consciousness, however, there is neither birth nor death, because everything is ultimately an appearance upon Consciousness.
“Just as from a magical seed grows an equally illusory sprout—being neither eternal nor destructible—so too is the logic of birth and death applicable to objects.”
And again:
“About the birthless Reality, the terms ‘eternal’ and ‘non-eternal’ are inapplicable. No categorical statement can be made about That to which words themselves do not apply.”
—Translations by Swami Gambhirananda, Eight Upanishads
K 61–62
These verses reiterate K 29–30 of Chapter III. It is relatively easy to explain the waking state with the help of the dream state. During a dream, one mind appears to split into the subject and the object. Likewise, in the waking state, the one mind appears as the subject and the object because all experiences are ultimately thoughts in the mind. What, then, is the role of Consciousness? Consciousness, by Its mere presence, lends sentiency to the mind. Since the mind and Consciousness are inseparable, every experience takes place in the presence of Consciousness.
K 63–66
During a dream, the dream mind experiences various creatures. The mind is the subject, while the dream creatures are its objects. Consciousness, as the witness of the mind, is the ultimate subject, and the mind itself is its object. On waking, the dream is sublated. It is recognized as mithya although it appeared real while the dream lasted.
The same principle applies to the waking state. The waking mind experiences a variety of objects and beings. These are objects to the mind, while the mind itself is an object to Consciousness. Thus, all experiences occur in Consciousness. Just as the dream world is sublated on waking, the waking world is ultimately sublated by Self-knowledge. Therefore, it too is mithya.
K 67
The mind and its objects are mutually dependent. The existence of an object is not established unless it is experienced by a mind. Likewise, in the absence of objects, the mind has no thoughts and becomes a “no-mind,” as in deep sleep. Because of this mutual dependence, both the mind and the world are mithya.
K 68–70
Dream objects appear when a person begins to dream and disappear when the person either wakes up or returns to deep sleep. Thus, dream objects have no independent reality. They are like the objects seen in a magic show, where the magician makes things appear and disappear. The same applies to the extraordinary experiences produced by medicines, charms, or supernatural powers (siddhis).
K 71
The doctrine of ajativada, introduced in K 48 of Chapter III, is reiterated here. No jiva is ever born, nor is the world ever truly born. Both are merely appearances. Swami Paramarthananda points out that mithyavada and ajativada express the same truth from two different standpoints, just as saying “the cup is half full” and “the cup is half empty” convey the same fact. Saying that the world has no real existence is mithyavada; saying that it is never truly born is ajativada.
K 72–74
The apparent duality is nothing but the seeming manifestation of non-dual Consciousness in association with the mind. Strictly speaking, there is no real association, because Consciousness is ever free from objects. The subject-object distinction is merely the mind’s projection.
Whatever exists in the empirical world lacks absolute reality, even though many philosophical schools regard it as real. The Absolute transcends all words and concepts. Even the term “birthless” is only a provisional expression used to negate the mistaken notion that Brahman is born.
K 75–81
Those with a materialistic outlook are fascinated by duality because they are driven by the pursuit of “the other”—something to acquire, possess, or enjoy. Desires and the actions arising therefrom may be broadly classified into three categories. The highest are scripturally enjoined actions, which lead to higher realms or births. The intermediate are ordinary secular actions, which lead to human rebirth. The lowest are prohibited actions, which result in lower births.
When a person becomes free from desires, the knowledge of non-duality becomes easy to assimilate. He realizes that his true nature has always been the birthless, causeless, eternal, non-dual Consciousness. Consequently, he is freed from saṃsara.
K 82–84
Gauḍapada recognizes that ajativada is difficult to understand and assimilate. One obstacle is attachment to materialism; another is the confusion created by conflicting philosophical theories concerning the existence or non-existence of the Self. These theories have already been examined and refuted.
A reflective seeker, however, is not swayed by such disputes. Through inquiry, he discovers the Self and becomes enlightened.
K 85–86
The Upanishads declare that the knower of Brahman is Brahman. Such a person knows that he is complete and therefore free from desires. The transactions of the world neither add to nor subtract from his fullness.
He continues to live like any other person. The body and mind continue to experience pleasure and pain, but he no longer suffers mentally because he does not identify with them. Experiencing pain is different from suffering. This freedom becomes effortless and natural because Self-knowledge is a living reality for him. He is firmly established in tranquillity.
K 87–89
Gauḍapada once again reviews the three states of experience and the fourth, called Turiya. The waking and dream states are states of duality, involving the experiencer, the experienced object, and the process of experience. The only difference is that dream objects are subtle, whereas waking objects are gross.
In deep sleep there is no manifest duality, yet ignorance persists.
Turiya, although called the “fourth,” is not a state. It is the ever-present reality underlying the other three. In It, the triad of knower, known, and knowledge is absent. It is birthless, non-dual, transcendent of the three states, and at the same time their immanent substratum.
The wise know all three states but identify only with Turiya. They remain enlightened forever.
Shankaracharya comments:
“…since his realization relates to that which transcends the whole universe. Once one’s true nature has been realized, that realization never departs. Unlike the knowledge of the sophists, there is neither rise nor decline in the knowledge of one who has realized the highest Truth.”
—Swami Gambhirananda, Eight Upanishads, Advaita Ashrama
Contd