Q: I understand that knowledge is the key and, once that is gained, experience is no longer relevant. But there is still confusion with respect to consciousness; trying to be in a certain state or feeling of freedom, lightness, etc.
A: You are right that ‘experience’ never matters. But being told something once, and accepting it as true, does not mean that doubts will not arise later. If you have heard the (correct) teaching of Advaita through to its conclusion, that is śravaṇa. And if you have understood and accepted it, asking (and having answered) any questions as you go, that is manana. But not being 100% sure means that you still need nididhyāsana. That is normal.
In order to resolve this, you are obliged to ‘revisit’ the teaching – reading, listening, thinking about, talking about, etc. until there are no further concerns. Firmly believing the teaching means you are a jñānī; never having any second thoughts about it and living your life in the complete understanding of it is being a jīvanmukta. You can expect the nididhyāsana stage to take years, if not the rest of your life!
Every’thing’ is Consciousness. Whatever your state or feeling, you are always only Consciousness. Those thoughts are arising in Consciousness. You can never be anything else (no matter how hard you try).
Q: The reason why I’m having this struggle is because there’s so much about “The Consciousness Principle” being what we are and how it’s separate and completely independent of objects, etc. that I keep thinking I need to ‘just be that’, and not be concerned with or about mithyā, for example. This makes things seem completely dualistic.
A: Consciousness is not separate from or independent of anything because there IS nothing else. Mithyā means that whatever you are talking about and calling mithyā is actually really Consciousness. How can that be dualistic?
What are you actually doing for your nididhyāsana (apart from asking me questions – 😉)? What books are you reading and/or talks listening to? Have you read Venugopal’s series on the website? His complete book, which covers the whole of Advaita teaching according to Swamis D and P, is serialized here. Another powerful ‘nididhyāsana’ book you can buy I reviewed here. Best of all, as I’m sure I must have said before, would be Swami D’s Bhagavad Gita Home Study course. This covers everything, and is very readable and authoritative. OK – it seems expensive – but what is money in relation to knowledge?